Bobby Benson's baby band is turning the entire Muppet Theater upside down and it's up to their guest star, Joan Cusack to turn it right side up again.
- The guest star's dressing room: Scooter knocks on Joan Cusack's dressing room door 5 times and tells her 18 2nds 'til curtain and Joan agrees to do the show with them.
- The All-New Muppet Show Theme Song: Gonzo's bugle imitates a whoopee cushion deflating.
- Opening Musical Number: Bobby Benson's baby band sings Down by the Bay
- Statler comments to Waldorf that he once went on a vacation trip to Hawaii and Waldorf comments to Statler that he's been to Disney World himself.
- Bear on Patrol sketch number: Animal's framed for tearing apart a newspaper and he proves to Patrol Bear and Officer Hogthrob that he didn't do it.
- Waldorf comments to Statler that he used to read mystery detective books in his younger years and Statler comments to Waldorf that he used to watch mystery detective movies himself.
- Talk Spot: Kermit and Joan talk about what they like to do out in the park.
- The Swedish Chef sketch number: Rice Meatballs
- Pigs in Space sketch number: Dr. Strangepork's invention which is called the Shrinkinator 900 causes 1st Mate Piggy and Link Hogthrob to shrink down to the size of action figures.
- Statler comments to Waldorf that space shows are super scientific and Waldorf comments to Statler that he's lucky that there's no space monsters around here.
- Veterinarian's Hospital sketch number: Dr. Teeth as the patient
- Waldorf comments to Statler that he once went to a hospital to have his terrible tonsils taken out and Statler comments to Waldorf that he once went there for his flu shots.
- Muppet Labs sketch number: Bunsen and Beaker present their new invention: Radioactive Banana Cream Pudding which Beaker eats and it causes him to flash brightly.
- Statler comments to Waldorf that the pudding sure looks radioactive and Waldorf comments to Statler that Beaker sure is flashing brightly.
- Closing musical number: You're the 1 That I Want (sung by Rizzo and Yolanda)
- Matt Vogel as Kermit, Robin, Floyd, Lew Zealand, Crazy Harry, Dr. Strangepork, Uncle Deadly and Baby Number 1 (voices)
- Eric Jacobson as Miss Piggy, Fozzie, Animal, Sam, Marvin Suggs and Baby Number 2 (voices)
- Dave Goelz as Gonzo, Beauregard, Zoot, Waldorf, Chip and Baby Number 3 (voices)
- Billy Barkhurst as Link Hogthrob (voice)
- David Rudman as Scooter, Janice, Wayne, Bobby Benson and Mildred Huxtetter (voices)
- Peter Linz as Walter, Gloria Estefan, Bean, Rizzo, Statler, Beaker and Baby Number 4 (voices)
- Alice Dinnean Vernon as Wanda, Hilda and Afghan Hound (voices)
- Bill Barretta as Johnny, Pepe, Rowlf, the Swedish Chef and Dr. Teeth (voices)
- Brian Henson as Sal and Dr. Neuter (voices)
- Ryan Dillon as Clifford, Mulch and Polly Lobster (voices)